Mike covets Chuck’s car, which Chuck just inherited from his late father, but Joe also wants to buy the vehicle. Meanwhile, Vanessa is honest about how much she dislikes Kyle’s…

The Baxters meet Rob, Eve’s new boyfriend, at Christmas dinner, and Mike’s unsure if he approves of him. Meanwhile, Mandy persuades Kristin to drop hints to Kyle about what he…

A former janitor becomes a potential key witness, but Peter and Sam struggle to track him down. Meanwhile, they examine a student trip to Costa Rica.

An interview with a former St. Bernardine student gives the guys confidence that they’re on the right track with their most recent theory.

A student’s sudden lack of cooperation slows the investigation, but an incident in the school parking lot sends Peter and Sam down a new path.

Who is the Turd Burglar, and why did they do it? Are Peter and Sam still chasing the truth, or has it been right under their nose the whole time?

As Peter learns more about basketball star DeMarcus Tillman, he uncovers evidence of athletes getting preferential treatment at St. Bernardine.

As Sam and Peter comb through digital clues, they hope a technology glitch might open up some new leads. But a low-tech discovery leaves them reeling.

Peter and Sam highlight Kevin McClain and his friendships as they start to break down the version of events supported by the school and police.

Peter and Sam travel to a prestigious private high school in Bellevue, Washington, to document the story of a filthy vandal called the “Turd Burglar.”